10/06/2010

And the caddie "lost the ball""

At the International Junior Women's tournament in La Cala Resort, a player deemed her ball unplayable and threw it into a ravine.

During the second day of the 2010 Spanish International Junior Women's Championship, held at La Cala Resort, the second shot of one of the players…

During the second day of the 2010 Spanish International Junior Women's Championship, held at La Cala Resort, the second shot of one of the players, on the par five of Hole 15, came to rest inside a bush located to the left of the fairway.

Having no possibility of playing it, she decided to consider her ball unplayable. Once her ball was identified, and in order to apply Rule 28, the player marked and lifted the ball and, overcome with anger, threw the ball into the adjacent ravine.

The player was four holes away from completing her final qualifying round for the Match Play phase, and she thought that with that bad shot she had lost all chance of qualifying.

She asked her caddie for a ball, and he mistakenly told her that the Rules didn't allow her to change balls under the Unplayable Ball Rule and that she had to drop the ball she had just thrown into the ravine. In desperation, the player hurried down the ravine in search of her ball, at which point, fortunately, a referee appeared.

The umpire explained to the player that the last paragraph of Rule 28, Unplayable Ball, states that “when proceeding under this Rule, the player may pick up and clean his ball or replace it with another ball.”

The relieved player abandoned the search for her original ball and proceeded to drop a ball under Rule 28c within two club-lengths of the spot where the original ball lay in the bush, no closer to the hole, after which she managed to save par with a superb approach and even better putt.

One of the fundamental principles of golf, stated in Rule 15-1, says that “a player must finish the hole with the ball played from the teeing ground.” However, Rule 15-2 also tells us that “a player may substitute a ball when proceeding under a Rule that permits the player to play, drop, or place another ball to complete play of a hole.”

When we put a ball into play under the Water Obstruction Rule (Rule 26), the Lost or Out of Bounds Rule (Rule 27), or the Unplayable Ball Rule (Rule 28), we are allowed to substitute the original ball with another ball, even if we have the original ball at hand. However, when we take relief under the Obstruction Rule (Rule 24) or the Abnormal Ground Conditions Rule (Rule 25-1), we must use the ball we were originally playing, unless we have not been able to find it or it is not immediately recoverable. We must also use the ball we were originally playing when taking relief under the Embedded Ball Rule (Rule 25-2) or the Wrong Green Rule (Rule 25-3).

Unfortunately, the referee's explanations and the player's excellent recovery were not enough for the player to advance to the decisive Match Play phase to fight for the championship.

Anecdotally, at the 2010 Spanish Open held at the Real Club de Golf de Sevilla, a player's caddie suffered the exact same confusion regarding the Rules. Unfortunately for the spectator who had to return the ball to the player after having given it to him, on this occasion there was no umpire on hand to correct the player's mistake.

If you ever decide to throw your ball into a ravine, you'd better have visited the Rules Section from the website.

Related content

Latest News

More news

Related News

08/06/2010

María Elena Villamil wins the Spanish Junior Women's International

She beat Finland's Noora Tamminen in the grand final on the 17th hole