27/06/2010

A very renowned event

In the Regional Pitch & Putt Final, the results of three players were recorded on the wrong scorecard.

At the end of the first day of the Regional Pitch & Putt Final, held this weekend at La Siesta Golf Club, in…

At the end of the first day of the Regional Pitch & Putt Final, held this weekend at La Siesta Golf Club in Málaga, a curious rules incident occurred. The scores recorded on the scorecards of three players did not match the strokes they had actually taken, and to make matters worse, all three players were part of the same group.

After studying the scorecards of the players involved, the Committee realized that the players had recorded the scores on the wrong card, so that the cards were perfectly correct in all other respects, except that the name on each one was not that of the player whose score was recorded.

As a result, the Committee concluded that the players, when exchanging the cards with the corresponding marker, had become confused and had exchanged them incorrectly.

What happened is strikingly similar to an incident that occurred on the third day of the 2003 Open Championship at Royal St George's. On that occasion, Jesper Parnevick and Mark Roe, playing in the same group, forgot to exchange scorecards. Jesper recorded Mark's scores on his own scorecard, and Mark recorded Jesper's scores on his own. At the end of the round, they signed and handed in their scorecards, just as happened this weekend at La Siesta.

In 2003, Decision 6-6d/4 stated that if players forgot to exchange scorecards, as happened to Roe and Parnevik, and any score on any hole was lower than the actual score, the player would be disqualified. In the case of Roe and Parnevik, this resulted in the disqualification of both players. Ultimately, this unfortunate incident led the R&A to amend Decision 6-6d/4 in 2006, which now reads:

6-6d/4 The Competitor's Result Recorded on the Card with the Name of His/Her Partner-Competitor and Vice Versa

PA and B play together in a stroke play competition. A is B's marker, and B is A's marker. The starter distributes a scorecard to each player. When the scorecards are returned, the card with A's name printed on it contains B's correct score, and vice versa. Each scorecard contains the signature of the competitor whose score is recorded, along with the signature of their marker.
The discrepancy between the printed names of the competitors and the recorded results is discovered after the cards have been returned. What is the decision?

R Assuming that each competitor has signed the scorecard on which their scores were recorded and that the marker has also signed this card, the Committee should delete (cross out) the printed name on the card, write down the name of the competitor whose scores are recorded on the card, and accept each player's card without penalty. Administrative errors of this nature are not covered by the Rules, and the Committee should correct such an error. There is no time limit for correcting this administrative error. Rule 6-6b implies that the competitor is responsible only for the correct recording of the score for each hole, ensuring that the marker has signed their scorecard and that they themselves have also signed it.
The same principle would apply if a results card were handed out with no name written on it.

In the case of what happened in the Regional Pitch&Putt Final, the Committee, in view of the current wording of Decision 6-6d/4, proceeded to rectify the names of the competitors on the scorecards and accept them, without penalty.

To be named as an example of a Rule-abiding person, regularly visit the Rules Section from the web.

Latest News

More news