After the implementation of the SMH, lower-level players with higher handicaps have, in many cases, seen their handicaps increase, even by 10 or more points.
This has alarmed many parents who believe that the increase discourages their children.
Furthermore, this recalculation also has an impact on the Spanish Children's, Junior and Benjamin Championships (especially the latter) since, due to the COVID-19 pandemic, it has not been possible to use the Access System to said championship based on valid rounds and the handicap of the players must be used.
The philosophy behind the new SMH calculation is based on averaging the players' best rounds, specifically the best 8 of the last 20; this makes the SMH a system that gives more importance to the average level of play, whereas the EGA system relied more on individual results to make handicap adjustments, and therefore a very good result caused a large handicap reduction.
High handicaps, and especially the lower categories, are perhaps the group of players where the new calculation philosophy has the greatest impact due to their inconsistency and the fact that handicaps of 26.5 or higher could not be raised by submitting results.
Another difference between the EGA and SMH handicaps lies in the slower impact on the handicap of players whose level of play is constantly improving. Again, children are a prime example of this, especially those new to the world of handicap.
Finally, another factor to consider is the practice of some clubs assigning handicaps too early, with the well-intentioned aim of encouraging players to enter the world of competition. Under the EGA system, it didn't matter if a player was assigned their first handicap too early, as it would automatically be lowered once they achieved a score below their handicap.
RULES OF THE WORLD HANDICAP SYSTEM
Rule 7 of the SMH states that the Competition Committee will have two mechanisms for modifying the handicap of its players: Handicap Review and Handicap Adjustment (what in EGA was known as Appraisal). See Rule 7 of the World Handicap System Rules.
There is a significant difference between a Handicap Review and a Handicap Adjustment (Appraisal). The former is carried out under established procedures (Appendix D) by comparing trends and developments, while the latter is a discretionary decision of the Competition Committee.
Therefore, the RFEG has decided:
1.- Carry out an ex officio Handicap Review for all Benjamin players with a handicap of 26.5 or higher as of July 24, 2020, based on the average of the 2 best results since January 1, 2019. The result of the Review may not grant a handicap lower than 26.5.
2. For Under-12 and Under-14 players, a Handicap Review will be carried out on October 1st at the player's request through their Competition Committee. Instructions on how to request this review will be published later.
3.- The Review will only serve to lower the handicap.
4.- Those players who play a competition on the same day as the Handicap Review, will play for all purposes with their handicap prior to the review.
For example, a junior player with a handicap above 26.5 will have their handicap review on July 24th without needing to request it. From that date onwards, their handicap will be modified by the SMH, so their handicap (while it remains above 26.4) cannot be increased unless they request a quarterly handicap review from the committee.
The RFEG believes that with these measures the transition from the EGA handicap to the WHS for lower category players will be more appropriate and will better reflect the level of play.