21/06/2010

Brian Davis and the Honor Game

On the first playoff hole of the 2010 Verizon Heritage PGA Tour, Brian Davis violated Rule 13-4, which ultimately cost him the championship.

The Harbour Town golf course was a prime example of how golf remains a game of honor. During the day's events…

The Harbour Town golf course was a prime example of how golf remains a game of honor. During Sunday's round of the 2010 Verizon Heritage, Jim Furyk and Brian Davis finished tied after 72 holes and had to play a hole-by-hole playoff.

On the first playoff hole, Brian Davis's second shot landed in the water hazard next to the green. With the ball in a good position, Brian decided to play it from there. A decent shot, given the circumstances, put Brian's ball on the green, giving him a chance to save par and continue the playoff on the next hole.

However, as he raised his club to make the shot, Brian felt it brush against a reed next to his ball. “I thought I’d seen something moving out of the corner of my eye, so I told myself we could check it out on TV,” Davis said.

Not being sure if this had actually happened, Brian informed Slugger White, the PGA Tour's chief referee, who asked for the television footage to be reviewed, after which he confirmed to Brian that he had indeed touched the rod.

It only remained to determine whether the reed was a loose impediment, or was growing, in view of what was prescribed in Rule 13-4c:

Except as otherwise provided in the Rules, before making a stroke at a ball which is in a hazard (whether a bunker or a water hazard) or which, having been lifted from a hazard, may be dropped or placed in the hazard, the player shall not:
…
c. Touching or moving a loose impediment that rests on or touches the obstacle.

However, according to the Note to the Rule,

At any time, including in the preparation of the stroke or in the backswing of the club to execute the stroke, the player may touch with a club or otherwise any obstruction, any construction declared by the Committee to be an integral part of the course, or any grass, shrub, tree or other growing thing

Thus, whether the reed was a loose impediment or was still growing was a fundamental factor in determining whether Brian had incurred any kind of penalty, since, according to the definition of loose impediments,

“Loose impediments” are natural objects, including:

– stones, leaves, small wood, branches and the like,

– excrement,

– earthworms, insects and the like; and waste and piles formed by these,

provided they are not:

– fixed or growing,

– solidly embedded, or

– attached to the ball.
…

After Slugger White confirmed that the reed was not growing, but was in fact a loose impediment, Brian had to add two penalty strokes to his score for the hole for a Rule 13-4c violation, which proved decisive in Furyk winning the playoff hole and the championship.

“It’s obviously a tough loss for him, and I respect and admire him for what he’s done,” Furyk said, referring to Brian Davis. In Slugger White’s words, “What Davis has lost on the field, his reputation will more than make up for with his honorable performance. He’ll be repaid tenfold.”.

We are sure that a regular visit to the Rules Section from the website.

Related content

Latest News

More news