16/07/2010

German Flags

In the Women's European Team Championship, the foursomes on Saturday morning, in the clash between Germany and Scotland for the bronze medal, led to a Rules situation that spread like wildfire among the participants.

In the foursome match between Pia Halbig and Thea Hoffmeister of Germany against the Scottish pair Pamela Prestwell and Laura Murray,…

Text in English below

In the foursome match between Germany's Pia Halbig and Thea Hoffmeister and Scotland's Pamela Prestwell and Laura Murray, the German pair's tee shot on the 5th hole, a 154-meter par three, landed to the left of the flagstick, off the green. The Germans, playing their second shot first, opted for a perfectly executed chip that landed against the flagstick with half the ball in the hole.

However, what seemed like a fantastic birdie wasn't going to be. The German players, overcome with joy, retrieved the ball from the hole without it having been sunk.

Indeed, Rule 17-4 states that “when a player’s ball lies against the flagstick in the hole and the ball is not holed, the player or another person authorized by him may move or remove the flagstick and if the ball falls into the hole the player is deemed to have holed with his last stroke; otherwise, if the ball has been moved it must be placed on the edge of the hole, without penalty.”

In this case, the ball was not potted, since according to the definition of potted ball, “a ball is potted when it lies within the circumference of the hole and is entirely below the level of the rim of the hole.“ As half the ball was above the rim of the hole, the ball was not potted, and the players should have applied Rule 17-4, cited above.

The players called a referee, who proceeded to explain to them the content of Decision 17-4/1, which deals precisely with the situation raised:

17-4/1 Ball supported against the raised flagstick before being potted

A player's ball is resting against the flagstick, but not pocketed since part of it protrudes above the level of the hole. However, the player, believing it is pocketed, lifts it. What is the ruling?

The player incurs a one-stroke penalty under Rule 20-1 for lifting the ball without marking its position. The player must replace the ball against the flagstick and may then apply Rule 17-4.

Following the decision, the players replaced the ball against the flagstick, and after moving the flagstick, the ball fell into the hole, resulting in a final score of par. Fortunately for them, par was enough to win the hole, although it wouldn't ultimately be enough to win the match or the bronze medal, which went to the Scottish team.

Regardless of how good he is at chipping, take a look at the Rules Section from the web.

Click here to watch the video.

German Flags

At the European Ladies Amateur Team Championship, the Saturday morning foursomes, in the match between Germany and Scotland for the bronze medal, gave way to a Rules situation which quickly spread among participants.

In the foursome match confronting Pia Halberg and Thea Hoffmeister, from Germany, against Scottish Pamela Prestwell and Laura Murray, Germany's tee shot at the fifth hole, a 154 meters par three, landed to the left of the pin, off the putting-green. The German players, first to play their second shot, tried a perfectly executed chip shot which ended resting against the flagstick, with half the ball inside the hole.

However, what seemed to be a fantastic birdie wasn't so. The German players, in the heat of the moment, lifted the ball from the hole before it was holed.

Indeed, Rule 17-4 says that “when a player's ball rests against the flagstick in the hole and the ball is not holed, the player or another person authorized by him may move or remove the flagstick, and if the ball falls into the hole, the player is deemed to have holed out with his last stroke; otherwise, the ball, if moved, must be placed on the lip of the hole, without penalty.”

In our case, the ball was not holed since, according to the definition of holed, “a ball is «holed» when it is at rest within the circumference of the hole and all of it is below the level of the lip of the hole.” As half the ball was above the level of the lip of the hole, the ball was not holed, and the players had to apply Rule 17-4, as stated above.

The players called for a referee, who proceeded to explain them Decision 17-4/1, which precisely deals with the situation:

17-4/1 Ball Resting Against Flagstick Lifted Before Being Holed

QA player's ball is resting against the flagstick, but it is not holed because all of it is not below the level of the lip of the hole. However, the player, believing the ball is holed, picks it up. What is the ruling?

A The player incurs a penalty stroke under Rule 20-1 for lifting his ball without marking its position. The player must replace the ball against the flagstick and may then apply Rule 17-4.

Following this decision, the players proceeded to replace the ball against the flagstick and, after moving it, the ball felt into the hole, for a final score of par. Fortunately, par was enough to win the hole, but it wasn't enough for winning either the match or the bronze medal, finally awarded to the Scottish Team.

Regardless of how good you are at chipping, have a look at the Rules at www.randa.org.

Click here to see the video

Related content

Latest News

More news