During play on the 14th hole, Ross Fisher's ball went into a wooded area, the well-known cork oaks of Valderrama. Having failed to locate it by the volunteers, the player and his party began searching for the ball, at which point a referee started the stopwatch. After a thorough search, it appeared that Ross would have no option but to invoke Rule 27-1c, which states that “if a ball is lost as a result of not having been found or identified as his by the player within five minutes after the player’s party or his/her caddies have begun their search, the player shall play a ball, under penalty of one stroke, as nearly as possible to the spot from which the original ball was last played. (See Rule 20-5).”.
However, when the referee's stopwatch reached four minutes, a ball suddenly fell from the sky, or rather from the branches of one of the cork oak trees in the area where they were looking for the ball.
The ball, which had been stuck in the tree for quite some time, was identified by Ross Fisher as his own. It only remained to determine what Ross should do according to the Rules. And to do that, it was necessary to know what had caused the ball to move and fall from the tree.
If the ball's movement had been caused by Ross Fisher or his caddie while searching for it, Ross would have incurred a penalty stroke under Rule 18-2a and would have had to replace his ball in the tree. Indeed, a similar situation is addressed in Decision 18-2a/28:
18-2a/28 Ball dislodged from a tree; circumstances in which the player incurs a penalty
A player couldn't find his ball. Believing it might be stuck in a tree, he shook the tree and the ball fell to the ground. He played it from where it came to rest. What is the decision?
R The player incurred a one-stroke penalty under Rule 18-2a for moving the ball. He should have replaced the ball. By failing to do so, in Match Play he lost the hole and in Stroke Play he incurred a total of two penalty strokes (see Rule 18 penalty information).
However, Ross had not done any of the things described in this decision, merely looking for his ball on the ground.
It is possible, then, that Robert Rock, Ross Fisher's fellow competitor, or any of those assisting in the search for the ball, caused it to move. In this case, the applicable Rule would have been Rule 18-1, which states that "if a ball at rest is moved by an external cause, there is no penalty and the ball must be replaced."“
But again, that wasn't the case either. The size and strength of the tree trunk and the fact that no one had tried to locate the ball in the trees suggested that no external cause had caused the ball to move, the most likely cause being the strong prevailing wind.
According to the definition of an external cause, “neither wind nor water is an external cause” so there was only one Rule applicable to the situation, Rule 13-1, which says that “the ball shall be played as it lies, unless the Rules provide otherwise.”
So Ross had to play his ball from where it lay on the ground after falling out of the tree, managing to finish the hole with a bogey.
To help you understand which rule applies to any given situation, regularly visit the Rules Section from the website.