During the first day of the World University Championship, held at Antequera Golf, the balls of three players were resting on the green of Hole 8. As the players approached the green, a dog from a nearby property, which had managed to enter the course, decided that it was a good opportunity to get started in golf and began to play with the balls of the three players, moving them from where they rested on the green and away from the hole.
According to Rule 18-1, “if a ball at rest is moved by an external cause, there is no penalty and the ball must be replaced.”
And the Note to Rule 18-1 goes on to say that “it is a question of fact whether or not a ball has been moved by an external cause. In order to apply this Rule, it must be known or practically certain that an external cause has moved the ball. In the absence of such knowledge or practical certainty, the player must play the ball as it lies or, if the ball is not found, proceed under Rule 27-1.”
Fortunately for the players, some volunteers from the organization observed the events, and were able to assure the players that their balls had been moved by the dog, and help them determine where the balls were resting before the dog, an external cause, moved them.
After consulting with a referee, the players replaced the balls on the green, in the place where they were estimated to be lying, thus being able to finish the hole.
Incidents caused by external factors are very common on the field. What is not so common is for the external factor to be a referee, and even less so for it to be two.
During the final round on Friday, a player's ball, while in motion after their tee shot on the 14th hole, was deflected by an external factor, or more precisely, by a referee, who had to be treated by the tournament's medical staff. But hours later, on the same day, another player's tee shot on the 3rd hole struck another referee.
The positive side is that both players immediately had a referee available, albeit not in the best condition, to explain that, according to Rule 19-1, “if the player’s moving ball is accidentally deflected or stopped by any external cause [such as a referee], it is an eventuality of the game, there is no penalty and the ball must be played as it lies, except:
a. If the player's moving ball after a stroke executed off the green is to come to rest in or upon a moving or animate alien cause, the ball must be dropped on the course or in a hazard or placed on the green as near as possible to the spot directly below the place where the ball came to rest in or upon the alien cause but not nearer to the hole, and
b. If the player's ball in motion after a stroke made on the putting green is stopped or deflected by, or comes to rest in or on, any moving or animate extraneous cause other than a worm, insect, or the like, the stroke is cancelled. The ball must be replaced and played again.
If the ball is not immediately recoverable, it may be replaced with another ball.”
If you ever accidentally hit an umpire with a ball, or encounter a playful dog on the field, don't miss the opportunity to show off what you've learned by visiting the Rules Section from the web.